TARGET FOR IQ · LEGAL CURRENT AFFAIRS
Supreme Court strikes down domicile-based reservations in PG medical admissions
Case study notes · 3 min read · English
Why in news?
A three-judge bench of the Supreme Court held that residence-based reservation in post-graduate (PG) medical courses violated the fundamental right to equality (Article 14).[18] Currently, seats for PG medical courses are filled by: (i) NEET ranking, (ii) state quotas, and (iii) institutional preferences.
Reporting month: January 2025. The month identifies this report, not a separately verified judgment date.
Facts at a glance
| Reporting period | January 2025 |
|---|---|
| Subject | Health & Education |
Detailed coverage
The Court was posed with the following questions: (i) whether residence-based reservations in PG courses is constitutionally permissible, (ii) if not, how must seats under state quota be filled, and (iii) if yes, what should be the share of state quota seats in all PG seats.
The Court held that the Constitution provides the right to seek admission in educational institutions across India. Differential treatment of students based on residence deters this right. However, domicile reservations are permissible in MBBS courses as they help address shortage of doctors in neglected regions. On the other hand, PG medical courses address the need for specialists and should thus enrol students based on marks and merit.
The Court ruled that all PG medical seats under state quotas should be filled based on performance in NEET. However, this will not apply to seats currently filled under state quota. The Court upheld the validity of seats filled through institutional preferences. These are seats granted to UG students of the same college. The Supreme Court stated that the share of such seats should be reasonable.
Reporting context
This is a historical report for January 2025. Proposals, draft rules and consultation deadlines are described as they stood in that reporting month; later enactments and revisions may differ.
For revision, connect the named institution, decision or proposal, affected sector and the figures stated in the report. Keep the reporting period attached to statistics and distinguish a proposal from a notified rule or enacted law.
GK/GS exam connection
Public health, education and social development. Identify the institution, target population and purpose of the intervention. Separate a proposed programme from a launched service, and a research finding from an approved public policy. Retain the population, period and units attached to reported statistics.
Source and credit: Anmol Kohli / PRS Legislative Research, Monthly Policy Review — January 2025. PRS content is available under Creative Commons Attribution 4.0. Changes: split into topic articles, reformatted, navigation and reading context added; source charts are omitted. No endorsement is implied. PRS states that it makes every effort to use reliable information but does not represent the content as accurate or complete.
Read all January 2025 current affairs · Search Legal Current Affairs